Issues to Consider About Significance Testing

1. When are the statistics calculated?

  • Table printing phase
  • Table building phase


2. What type of tables will be constructed?

  • Tables where a REGION is to be tested
  • Tables where the COLUMNS are tested
  • Independent Columns
  • Dependent Columns
  • Inclusive Columns
  • Repeated Measure
  • Tables where the ROWS are tested

3. Will the tables be weighted?
4. What is the statistical/percent base on the tables?
5. What Confidence level is needed?
6. Will all of the tables need to be stat tested?
7. Will all of rows on the table need to be tested?
8. Are there any special labeling options needed?
9. Are there any special table printing options needed?
10. Is there a request for a specific type of variance?
11. Is there enough room in the cell to print all of the letters?
12. Trouble Shooting
13. Chart Summarizing Statistical Tests Available

Examples of Tests Available and Discussion of Issues


2A. Table Printing Phase Statistics (REGION tests)


A) One-Way Analysis of Variance


ANOVA tests for significance between means.
Mutually Exclusive Rows
Mutually Exclusive Points Within Tested Banner Portions

Example specs: ANCHI.SPX
Example tables: TABLE.001

Syntax: EDIT={:TABLE_TESTS=[$R 1 TO 2 BY 1 TO LAST]TABLE_TESTS=[$R 3 TO 4 BY 1 TO LAST]TABLE_TESTS=[$R 5 TO 6 BY 1 TO LAST]}Syntax: LOCAL_EDIT={: COLUMN_STATISTICS_VALUES=VALUES(4,3,2,1)COLUMN_MEAN, COLUMN_STD, ANOVA}


B) Chi-Square


Testing to determine whether or not a relationship existsbetween two or more factors.
Mutually Exclusive Rows
Mutually Exclusive Points Within Tested Banner Portions

Example specs:ANCHI.SPX
Example tables: TABLE.002

Syntax: EDIT={:TABLE_TESTS=[$R 1 TO 2 BY 1 TO LAST]TABLE_TESTS=[$R 3 TO 4 BY 1 TO LAST]TABLE_TESTS=[$R 5 TO 6 BY 1 TO LAST]}Syntax: LOCAL_EDIT={: CHI_SQUARE }Syntax: [-COLUMN_STATISTICS_VALUES] DON'T KNOW/NOT SURE



2B1. Table Printing Phase Statistics (COLUMN tests)

A) All Possible Pairs Test

When more than two columns are tested at a time, this test willact as though each pair in the set of columns is being testedindividually.

Syntax: LOCAL_EDIT={:COLUMN_STATISTICS_VALUES=VALUES(10,...,1)STATISTICS_TESTS=I=BCDDO_STATS=.90}Syntax: [PRINT_ROW=MEAN, DO_STATISTICS=ALL_PAIRS]  MEAN

B) Newman-Keuls

This test uses information supplied by all the columns in the test toproduce a more reliable result.

Example specs:TT1.SPX
Example tables: TABLE.003

Syntax: LOCAL_EDIT={:COLUMN_STATISTICS_VALUES=VALUES(10,...,1)STATISTICS_TESTS=I=BCDDO_STATS=.90}Syntax: [PRINT_ROW=MEAN, DO_STATISTICS=NK]  MEAN


C) Kruskal-Wallis

This test is normally done on rating scales and treats theratings as ordinals instead of values.Tests printer means only.

Syntax: LOCAL_EDIT={:COLUMN_STATISTICS_VALUES=VALUES(10,...,1)STATISTICS_TESTS=I=BCDDO_STATS=.90}Syntax: [PRINT_ROW=MEAN, DO_STATISTICS=KW] MEAN


2B2. Table Building Phase Statistics (COLUMN Tests)

A) T-Tests

Print a T-Test instead of letters designating significance.

Example specs: TT2.SPX
Example tables: TABLE.004

Syntax: STATISTICS=: PRINTABLE_T I=BC,I=GHSyntax:  [STATS DO_T_TEST=11]  T[STATS DO_SIG_T=11]  SIGTSyntax: EDIT={: -STATS_FOOTNOTE }



B) Inclusive T-Tests

Can be printed as letters or t-values.

Example specs: TT3.SPX
Example tables: TABLE.005

Syntax: STATISTICS=: T=ABCDEFGSyntax: EDIT={: DO_STATISTICS=.90 }


C) All Possible Pairs (Default)


Example specs: APP.SPX
Example tables: TABLE.006

Syntax: STATISTICS=: ABCDEFG Syntax: EDIT={: ALL_POSSIBLE_PAIRS_TESTDO_STATISTICS=.90 }


D) Newman-Keuls

Syntax: STATISTICS=: AB,CD,EFGSyntax: EDIT={: NEWMAN_KEULS_TESTDO_STATISTICS=.90 }


E) Anova Scan

The ANOVA-Scan and Fisher tests are similar in that both firstperform an ANOVA (analysis of variance) on the set of columns,and then only test the individual columns if the ANOVA showssignificance.

Syntax: STATISTICS=: I=AB,I=CD,I=EFGSyntax: EDIT={: ANOVA_SCANDO_STATISTICS=.90 }


F) Fisher

The difference between the Anova Scan and the Fisher test, isthat the Fisher takes into account that multiple columns are being tested.

Syntax: STATISTICS=: I=AB,I=CD,I=EFGSyntax: EDIT={: FISHERDO_STATISTICS=.90 }

G) Repeated Measures

Everyone is in every banner point orA Person is in more than one banner point.

Used with Anova Scan
Used with Fisher

Example tables: TABLE.007

Syntax: STATISTICS=: RM=AB,RM=CD,RM=EFGH,RM=IJKL,RM=MNOPSyntax: EDIT={: DO_STATISTICS=.90 }

2C. Table Building Phase Statistics (ROW Tests)


A) Direct Comparison Tests

A direct comparison of two rows is similar to the test thatis performed on columns.


Example specs: DCDP.SPX
Example tables: TABLE.008

Syntax: STATISTICS=: D=1,2


B) Distributed Preference Tests

A distributed preference test allows a “No Preference” (orsimilar neutral third category) to be distributed betweenthe two original categories while ensuring the integrity ofthe underlying statistical test.


Example specs: DCDP.SPX
Example tables: TABLE.009
Syntax: ROW=: SELECT_VALUE([7^1/X],VALUES(1,.5)) WITH &SELECT_VALUE([7^2/X],VALUES(1,.5))Syntax: STATISTICS=: P=1,2



3. Will the tables be weighted?

One weight per table (default)
One weight per respondent
Weighted and unweighted data on the same table

Example specs: WGT.SPX

Syntax: ~SET MULTIPLE_WEIGHT_STATISTICS


4. What is the statistical/percent base on the tables?

A) One base
1. Total Row (default)
2. Any Response Row

Syntax: ~SET STATISTICS_BASE_ARSyntax: [BASE_ROW PRINT_ROW=AR VPER=AR] Base }

3. Reprint the base on subsequent pages

Syntax: [BASE_ROW PRINT_ROW=AR VPER=AR REPRINT_BASE] Base }


B) Base changes in the body of the table

Syntax: ROW=: $[BASE] [72^1.3] $[] &[5^0/1/2/3/4/5/6/7/8/9] BY [72^1.3] &$[MEAN,STD] [5] BY [72^1.3]Syntax: ROW=: $[FILTER_BASE] [72^1.3] $[] &[5^0/1/2/3/4/5/6/7/8/9] $[MEAN,STD] [5]Creates effective_n row that needs to be dealt with in the stub


5. What Confidence level is needed?

A) .80
(not usable with Newman-Keuls)

Syntax: EDIT={: DO_STATISTICS=.80 }


B) .90

Syntax: EDIT={: DO_STATISTICS=.90 }


C) .95(D
efault)

Syntax: EDIT={: DO_STATISTICS=.95 }


D) .99

Syntax: EDIT={: DO_STATISTICS=.99 }


E) approximately .nn (not usable with Newman-Keuls)

Syntax: EDIT={: DO_STATISTICS=APPROXIMATELY .85 }



F) bi-level

Syntax: EDIT={: DO_STATISTICS=.90+.95 }


6. Will all of the tables need to be stat tested?

A) All tables
B) Exclude specific table types like open-ends

Syntax: LOCAL_EDIT={: -DO_STATISTICS }Syntax: STATISTICS=;




7. Will all of rows on the table need to be tested?

A) All rows (means and percents)
B) Means only

Syntax: ~SET MEAN_STATISTICS_ONLY


C) Pick and choose on a table by table by table basis

Syntax: ROW=: [21^4,5] $[-DO_STATISTICS] [21^5/4/3] &$[DO_STATISTICS] [21^1,2] $[-DO_STATISTICS] [21^2/1]Syntax: ROW=: [21^(STATISTICS)4,5/5/4/3/(STATISTICS)1,2/2/1]



D) Rows that can’t be tested:

  1. *L modifier
  2. all summary statistics other than means
  3. any arithmetic operation
  4. sigma
  5. sums
  6. NUMBER_OF_ITEMS or any other number returning function


8. Are there any special labeling options needed?

A) Show letters that are assigned to columns

Syntax: [BASE_ROW] BASESyntax: [-BASE_ROW] TOTAL


B) Show footnote

———————————
(sig=.05) (all_pairs) columns tested BC, DEF, GHIJ

Syntax: EDIT={: STATS_FOOTNOTE }Syntax: EDIT={: -STATS_FOOTNOTE }



C) Change the default letters that are assigned to columns

Syntax: EDIT={: STAT_MARKING="ZYXW" }Syntax: EDIT={: -STAT_MARKING }



D) For T-Tests, print t-value or significance of any row whichhas stats tests

Syntax:  STATISTICS=: PRINTABLE_T I=AB,I=AC,I=AD,I=AE,I=AF,I=AGSyntax: [STATS, DO_T_TEST=*] T-VALUE[STATS, DO_SIG_T=*]  SIGNIFICANCESyntax: [STATS, DO_T_TEST=9] T-VALUE[STATS, DO_SIG_T=9]  SIGNIFICANCE OF TSyntax: [PRINT_ROW=MEAN] MEAN[PRINT_ROW=STD] STANDARD DEVIATION[PRINT_ROW=SE] STANDARD ERROR[DO_T_TEST=PRINT_MEAN] T-VALUE[DO_SIG_T=PRINT_MEAN] SIGNIFICANCE OF T


E) Mark_Chi_Square

Marks cells as significant based on chi-square testing. Foreach significant CHI_SQUARE test on the table, a formula isused to determine which cells are the most extreme.


Example specs: MCHI.SPX
Example tables: TABLE.010

Syntax:  EDIT={: MARK_CHI_SQUARE=ABCDE  }


F) Chi-Square or Anova printed in list form

Example specs: ANCHI.SPX
Example tables: TABLE.011
Syntax: EDIT={: -CHI_SQUARE_ANOVA_FORMAT }

G) Chi-square or Anova showing only the significance under the table

Syntax: EDIT={: SHOW_SIGNIFICANCE_ONLY }



9. Are there any special table printing options needed?


A) Don’t print stats on some rows

Syntax: [-DO_STATISTICS]  VERY GOOD

B) Only print stats when sufficient base

Minimum baseSyntax: EDIT={: MINIMUM_BASE=100 }Flag_minimum_baseSyntax: EDIT={: FLAG_MINIMUM_BASE }


10. Is there a request for a specific type of variance?

Syntax: EDIT={: SEPARATE_VARIANCE }

A) Paired Variance (default for All Possible Pairs when multiplepairs are tested, default for Direct Comparison Testing)

B) Pooled Variance (default for Newman-Keuls)
C) Separate Variance (independent tests only, inclusive tests only)
D) Usual Variance (default for t-tests)

11. Is there enough room in the cell to print all of the letters?

In Mentor the maximum number of lines that contain statsletters is eight lines.

The 8 lines would cover:

  1. A table where the maximum number of columns tested is 26 (so thatthe maximum number of stats letters to print would be 25)
  2. The minimum column width is 6 (5 stats letters per line)
  3. There is no room on the frequency line to print any letters
  4. There is no room on either the vertical or horizontal percent linesto print any letters
  5. Five more lines (or a total of 8 lines) would be needed to print 25letters

In addition to the other caveats above, the print file must alwayshave a width large enough to leave one blank column after therightmost frequency is printed. If you are printing percent signs,this blank has already been calculated in your page_width and you donot need an additional one.

12. Trouble Shooting

A. Error Messages in C-Mentor Manual 7.10.3 Error And Warning Messages
B. Statistical Formulas in C-Mentor Manual Appendix A
C. Statistics Dump

Syntax: ~SET STATISTICS_DUMP

Files Included:

  1. ANCHI.SPX Anova, Chi-Square
  2. APP.SPX All Possible Pairs, NK, Anova Scan, Fisher
  3. DCDP.SPXDirect Comparison, Distributed Preference
  4. MCHI.SPXMark Chi-Square
  5. TT1.SPXPrint phase All Possible Pairs, NK, KW
  6. TT2.SPXPrintable T-Tests
  7. TT3.SPXInclusive T-Tests
  8. WGT.SPXWeighting

  • issues.zip